Who's getting fired

[TerryBoats]

2 minutes ago, heyitsmeallen said:

Well it’s stellar compared to the last 5 years of Titans drafts. Carthon has 0

Reason to be fired. How many NFL teams have 4 rookies contributing to the team like the Titans do? And they didn’t even have a 3rd round pick. Calling for the GM to be fired when he had a great draft, and it was made known to the fans that this is a multiple year rebuild, is just stupid and shortsighted. 

The team is 3-12.  Being a modest contributor to a terrible team doesn't mean much at all .

 

By this time, Robinson had already drafted 3 All Pros and 4 players who would go on to be starters for a number of years, and they won a playoff game.

 

There's been some promise shown out of the rookie class.  But 2 draft classes in, I don't think we've seen anyone who looks like a future All-Pro or even that big of a difference maker in general.

[heyitsmeallen]

2 minutes ago, TitanPoke said:

Nobody expected that. Just to see some improvement, ANYWHERE.  Everything got worse.

OL(at least on the left side), secondary, and WR are better.  

[AussieTitanFan08]

Just now, heyitsmeallen said:

What would you have done differently? Did he not do everything he could to build up the shit roster that was left after Vrabel finally got shitcanned? Some fans just expect a shut roster to turn into a Super Bowl contender overnight. That’s not the reality of the NFL

 

You do realize the short term bump the top spender in FA usually receives, a study was done and the team that spends the most in FA ON AVERAGE improves by just over 3.5 wins the following season before things equalize or drop off.

[titansfan]

Just now, heyitsmeallen said:

What would you have done differently? Did he not do everything he could to build up the shit roster that was left after Vrabel finally got shitcanned? Some fans just expect a shut roster to turn into a Super Bowl contender overnight. That’s not the reality of the NFL

 

He did well. It was a good draft. His 1st and 2nd Round picks are starters which is thr expectation. And he got two other future significant contributers.  It was a good draft. But a couple of those players must play at a high level before calling it great

[heyitsmeallen]

4 minutes ago, TerryBoats said:

The team is 3-12.  Being a modest contributor to a terrible team doesn't mean much at all .

 

By this time, Robinson had already drafted 3 All Pros and 4 players who would go on to be starters for a number of years, and they won a playoff game.

 

There's been some promise shown out of the rookie class.  But 2 draft classes in, I don't think we've seen anyone who looks like a future All-Pro or even that big of a difference maker in general.

Sweat is a future all pro as well as Latham. Carthon himself said that this was really his first draft because Vrabel really controlled the team last year.

[oldschool]

26 minutes ago, AvgJoe said:

Thankfully I missed the game live today with the kids having games. 
 

But, my question is what area of the team is clearly improving and something to build on for next year?
 

When the answer is nothing, that’s a major problem

 

Funny enough special teams has been very good for about month now.

[VaTitan]

6 minutes ago, AussieTitanFan08 said:

 

He spent $300 million last offseason and the team got worse.

Wait, I thought Brinker was the polished, articulate shadow GM overseeing Carthon.  I guess Brinker gets the praise but none of the blame.  What do you think @BudsOilers?

[heyitsmeallen]

3 minutes ago, AussieTitanFan08 said:

 

You do realize the short term bump the top spender in FA usually receives, a study was done and the team that spends the most in FA ON AVERAGE improves by just over 3.5 wins the following season before things equalize or drop off.

What would you have done differently? If you’re going to criticize the GM. Tell us what you would have done differently. 

[heyitsmeallen]

A bunch of shortsighted emotional fans 

[oldschool]

Just now, heyitsmeallen said:

What would you have done differently? If you’re going to criticize the GM. Tell us what you would have done differently. 

 

It's a weak and lazy argument. Most of that money is tied up in Ridley, Cushenberry, Sneed, and Awuzie. Nearly everyone loved those moves.

[titansfan]

3 minutes ago, heyitsmeallen said:

Sweat is a future all pro as well as Latham. Carthon himself said that this was really his first draft because Vrabel really controlled the team last year.

 

I would not bet on it

[AussieTitanFan08]

1 minute ago, heyitsmeallen said:

What would you have done differently? If you’re going to criticize the GM. Tell us what you would have done differently. 

 

Firstly I would of accepted the gift the Rams dished up in the draft, secondly I would of had a veteran RT somewhere on the roster entering training camp, there is no way in hell I would of signed Murray to the money they did.

[heyitsmeallen]

1 minute ago, oldschool said:

 

It's a weak and lazy argument. Most of that money is tied up in Ridley, Cushenberry, Sneed, and Awuzie. Nearly everyone loved those moves.

That’s what I’m saying. A bunch of people saying Carthon should be fired are the same ones who loved his moves in the offseason. 

[titansfan]

Lot of guys accepting of a regression after what many consider a good to great offseason. Results matter. And I say this a fan of Carthon

[heyitsmeallen]

1 minute ago, AussieTitanFan08 said:

 

Firstly I would of accepted the gift the Rams dished up in the draft, secondly I would of had a veteran RT somewhere on the roster entering training camp, there is no way in hell I would of signed Murray to the money they did.

I def agree on the RT. The Murray contract is only like 7mill guaranteed. That’s basically nothing in NFL terms