Poll - Should the Titans draft Jeremiah Love at #4?

[IsntLifeFunny]

2 minutes ago, rns90 said:

The WR obviously. It’s been proven that you can cobble together a decent RB and win the superbowl without paying him top 5 RB

money

 

Right? If I thought Tate was Nico Collins you run to the podium if he's there at 4, especially in this draft. 

[rns90]

Just now, IsntLifeFunny said:

Right? If I thought Tate was Nico Collins you run to the podium if he's there at 4, especially in this draft. 

I actually think KC could outproduce Tate.  Given what we know about the Giants and KC preference for creators in space vs traditional big bodied WR.  Heck the Amon Ra St Brown example is perfect.  He does most of his work after the catch. He doesn’t have “traditional prototype size” either.

 

The only good thing about this info dump is that they will prioritize WR (Kuharsky listed WR as an area they will attack as well).

[NashvilleNinja]

3 minutes ago, IsntLifeFunny said:

Funny enough going through the list Tee Higgins was about my cutoff where I thought now there's an argument. Tee Higgins of Jahmyr Gibbs. It's close. On a rookie contract I think it goes to Higgins. 

 

But I for real just can't put Tate at that level. I've tried. And he has traits that translate, but I worry about him ever being a WR#1. I think his ceiling is Tee. 

 

Others think his ceiling is AJ Green. Somw have said Davante Adams.

 

You are horribly underselling him to make your want of Love look better. If Love is such a great pick you shouldn't feel you have to do that.

 

Tee Higgins wouldn't go in the top 10. He might not go until round 2. Most would probably take Bijan/Gibbs over Tee Higgins. Bijan/Gibbs over Green or Adams? That's a whole other debate.

 

Carnell Tate's ceiling is a higher tier up, whether you like him or not. The fact he's being projected to go within the first 5-7 picks says all you need to know about that.

 

At the end of the day, we'll see. Maybe teams actually think that. Maybe he'll drop out of the 1st altogether. Maybe he'll go somewhere in the middle. ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

[IsntLifeFunny]

5 minutes ago, NashvilleNinja said:

 

Others think his ceiling is AJ Green. Somw have said Davante Adams.

 

You are horribly underselling him to make your want of Love look better. If Love is such a great pick you shouldn't feel you have to do that.

 

Tee Higgins wouldn't go in the top 10. He might not go until round 2. Most would probably take Bijan/Gibbs over Tee Higgins. Bijan/Gibbs over Green or Adams? That's a whole other debate.

 

Carnell Tate's ceiling is a higher tier up, whether you like him or not. The fact he's being projected to go within the first 5-7 picks says all you need to know about that.

 

At the end of the day, we'll see. Maybe teams actually think that. Maybe he'll drop out of the 1st altogether. Maybe he'll go somewhere in the middle. ¯⁠\⁠_⁠(⁠ツ⁠)⁠_⁠/⁠¯

Has absolutely nothing to do with Love. I would be just fine with Bailey or Reese. I would take Tate over Styles, however. 

[IsntLifeFunny]

11 minutes ago, rns90 said:

I actually think KC could outproduce Tate.  Given what we know about the Giants and KC preference for creators in space vs traditional big bodied WR.  Heck the Amon Ra St Brown example is perfect.  He does most of his work after the catch. He doesn’t have “traditional prototype size” either.

 

The only good thing about this info dump is that they will prioritize WR (Kuharsky listed WR as an area they will attack as well).

Maybe I'm completely off. Tate does have some traits and similarities to a guy like Torry Holt, then again Holt had 1600 yards his last season in college...I would feel a lot more comfortable with Tate if we were drafting 12-15...but then I would be hoping to trade down and take my favorite WR prospect, Cooper Jr around 25 lol. 

 

If we draft Tate then I would have to think it means they see him as a surefire 1100+ WR, so I'm good with it if they go that direction. 

[Thrill]

If Love is generational, like LT, Walter Payton, Jim Brown good, then yeah he's worth the pick. It really just comes down to how high the evaluation of him is. The other calculation would be if he's still going to be a valuable player into his 30s like McCaffrey has been or to a lesser extent Henry has been. 

 

I'm not a scout but he looks fucking amazing. Darren McFadden crossed with Adrian Peterson with wayyy better hands. 

[oldschool]

9 hours ago, Thrill said:

If Love is generational, like LT, Walter Payton, Jim Brown good, then yeah he's worth the pick. It really just comes down to how high the evaluation of him is. The other calculation would be if he's still going to be a valuable player into his 30s like McCaffrey has been or to a lesser extent Henry has been. 

 

I'm not a scout but he looks fucking amazing. Darren McFadden crossed with Adrian Peterson with wayyy better hands. 

 

Heard a guy who covers the Giants say this morning that Love will be a very good pro but he isnt on Barkley's level as a prospect and thats whats needed to go top 5. He also said while Love has great tape a few things stood out to him

 

1. Love isnt great in pass protection and needs to be if you are going to use him in the passing game

 

2. Doesn't run with enough power

 

3. Is impatient at times

[JJHuddle12]

I've been on record to draft Reuben Bain and the Titans aren't doing that so trade down. People complain about Reese's stats against Indiana and Miami (rightfully so) but look how irrelevant Love was against the best defenses he faced.

[Callidus]

12 hours ago, IsntLifeFunny said:

Corey Davis is a really good comp for the top rated WR in this draft. 

Your best comp is bongo. 

[NashvilleNinja]

4 minutes ago, Callidus said:

Your best comp is bongo. 

 

 

[SleepingTitan]

42 minutes ago, Callidus said:

Your best comp is bongo. 

Surgical

[Callidus]

5 minutes ago, SleepingTitan said:

Surgical

Well played as well. 

[TerryBoats]

1 hour ago, JJHuddle12 said:

I've been on record to draft Reuben Bain and the Titans aren't doing that so trade down. People complain about Reese's stats against Indiana and Miami (rightfully so) but look how irrelevant Love was against the best defenses he faced.

There's far more contributing factors from others during Love's "bad" games - defenses stacking the box, OL losing matchups, team playing from behind, etc.  While Reese losing matchups is on him. 

 

Anyway, Love's combined numbers against ranked teams are still great:

 

Rushing Carries 136

Rushing Yards 898

Rushing YPC 6.6

Rushing Touchdowns 7

Receptions 30

Receiving Yards 286

Receiving Touchdowns 4

Total Scrimmage Yards 1,184

Total Touchdowns 11

[IsntLifeFunny]

57 minutes ago, Callidus said:

Well played as well. 

You really left some meat on that bone, which is not something I prescribe. 

[Callidus]

27 minutes ago, IsntLifeFunny said:

You really left some meat on that bone, which is not something I prescribe. 

No thinking before you prescribe something, you know that.