I mean, Tannehill is a good QB imo but he hasn't lit the world on fire. He was excellent against the Chargers consistently hitting guys in tight windows. Against the Bucs he was pretty bad against a bad defense and was gifted two touchdowns by Jameis. Against the Panthers, not great. Against the Chiefs it was the Henry show.
I do think that he's been great in clutch situations so far. which is important But this board is so anti-Mariota so of course they're going to get overly excited about him.
That being said, I do think Tannehill is a good QB and I'd resign him at $25 mil/year if need be. He's better than any rookie we'd get in the mid-late first round and unless we get Bridgewater, better than any off season QB that is available.