Jump to content
OILERMAN

The Game of Thrones

Recommended Posts

I'd argue there's less storyline than in first three seasons, which they converted well. I enjoy the narrative of books 4 and 5 but it certainly is a belabored subject. That's intentional for the books but a show could skip the belaboring and still address the same subjects and characters.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
16 minutes ago, Jamalisms said:

I'd argue there's less storyline than in first three seasons, which they converted well. I enjoy the narrative of books 4 and 5 but it certainly is a belabored subject. That's intentional for the books but a show could skip the belaboring and still address the same subjects and characters.

Books 4 and 5 are massive tomes. Books 1-3 were way easier to edit down into a TV season without drastic changes. I think you can easily look at what major plot points were changed from the book and (mostly) you can see that they needed to cut things from the plot to fit into the time allotted to them.

 

Dorne needed to be there because they had to kill Myrcella. But they didn’t need the rest of the plot from the book with Oldtown or Quentyn or FAegon.

 

Sansa didn’t stick around the Eyrie. Whatever plot is there for her got shifted to Winterfell because they had to off the Boltons. They were good villains and Sansa needed more screen time so it worked out putting them together. I think this worked well in the show (rape reactions aside). We have no idea what GRRM is planning to compare with.

 

FAegon himself is just an unnecessary component. I’m glad he is in the books but it’s easy to just remove him entirely from the show plot if he truly is a fake. They could have taken up the equivalent of an entire extra season just on FAegon's arc alone.

 

Arya and the Faceless Men pretty well followed the plot the books have used so far. I get why people don’t like how it ended, and GRRM will probably end it better. But they needed an expedited ending to fit their schedules. If the Waif had simply not stabbed her so seriously before their final showdown I think it would have been fine. The big argument seems to be that she couldn’t have healed so quickly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
48 minutes ago, Starkiller said:

There is way, way too much storyline in the books to include in a TV show. At least a 10 hour a season show. Maybe if HBO gave them 15 hours a season. Regardless, they had to streamline the plot to keep the story focused and still get to the destination.

 

As for Dorne, the book storyline is shit there, too...

I agree that streamlining was necessary.  Dorne is similar to Dany's story in that it is so separate from the rest of the Westeros stories.  Dany's is interesting because she has dragons.  Many have complained about the story lagging in Slaver's Bay as GRRM untangles the culture and politics of Slaver's Bay in a realistic fashion rather than a massive slaughter to make it convenient.  In the books, Dorne still has a part to play at least.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, titanruss said:

Nobody who watches the shows gives a damn about the swords. Thats just for the book junkies. 

 

But yeah.. Sam should have to answer for stealing it. They could have just avoided it altogether and had somebody grab it at the war when they got burned up. 

 

The arya storyline is what bothered me. zero consequences there. 

The jet packing was bad

jon is a bit contrived and his dead uncle coming out of nowhere to save him needs more explaination or it just feels like they are contriving some shit. 

theres plenty to complain about ...

 

but all in all, they had to write a couple of seasons with nothing to go on and not fuck it up too bad for when GRRM comes in to help clean up the finish.  they did .. just OK. more generic pop writing but its sufficed and had entertainment value. 

 

we'll see how the final season plays out. 

This is a very fair assessment. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Starkiller said:

Books 4 and 5 are massive tomes. Books 1-3 were way easier to edit down into a TV season without drastic changes. I think you can easily look at what major plot points were changed from the book and (mostly) you can see that they needed to cut things from the plot to fit into the time allotted to them.

 

Dorne needed to be there because they had to kill Myrcella. But they didn’t need the rest of the plot from the book with Oldtown or Quentyn or FAegon.

 

Sansa didn’t stick around the Eyrie. Whatever plot is there for her got shifted to Winterfell because they had to off the Boltons. They were good villains and Sansa needed more screen time so it worked out putting them together. I think this worked well in the show (rape reactions aside). We have no idea what GRRM is planning to compare with.

 

FAegon himself is just an unnecessary component. I’m glad he is in the books but it’s easy to just remove him entirely from the show plot if he truly is a fake. They could have taken up the equivalent of an entire extra season just on FAegon's arc alone.

 

Arya and the Faceless Men pretty well followed the plot the books have used so far. I get why people don’t like how it ended, and GRRM will probably end it better. But they needed an expedited ending to fit their schedules. If the Waif had simply not stabbed her so seriously before their final showdown I think it would have been fine. The big argument seems to be that she couldn’t have healed so quickly.

As I said, the books are massive because they belabor subjects that could be addressed in shorter order, not because they're chock full of new stuff.

 

Personal opinion is that removing FAegon renders Varys' and Illyrio's motivations completely bogus. I've had to explain to many people, including some here in this thread, what is going on there and why they're correct something is weird and unexplained ... because the rationale (and rationale for Dorne as well) was simply cut. FAegon ties a whole lot of shit together.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Starkiller said:

Books 4 and 5 are massive tomes. Books 1-3 were way easier to edit down into a TV season without drastic changes. I think you can easily look at what major plot points were changed from the book and (mostly) you can see that they needed to cut things from the plot to fit into the time allotted to them.

 

Dorne needed to be there because they had to kill Myrcella. But they didn’t need the rest of the plot from the book with Oldtown or Quentyn or FAegon.

 

Sansa didn’t stick around the Eyrie. Whatever plot is there for her got shifted to Winterfell because they had to off the Boltons. They were good villains and Sansa needed more screen time so it worked out putting them together. I think this worked well in the show (rape reactions aside). We have no idea what GRRM is planning to compare with.

 

FAegon himself is just an unnecessary component. I’m glad he is in the books but it’s easy to just remove him entirely from the show plot if he truly is a fake. They could have taken up the equivalent of an entire extra season just on FAegon's arc alone.

 

Arya and the Faceless Men pretty well followed the plot the books have used so far. I get why people don’t like how it ended, and GRRM will probably end it better. But they needed an expedited ending to fit their schedules. If the Waif had simply not stabbed her so seriously before their final showdown I think it would have been fine. The big argument seems to be that she couldn’t have healed so quickly.

They included Dorne because of the Red Viper.  They just miscalculated how poorly their versions of the Sand Snakes would be received.  Myrcella could have been killed in any number of ways - Dorne wasn't necessary for it.  Following the logic of "need", Dorne could have been cut out completely.

The show missed out on some great story-telling at Winterfell, in my opinion.  The "ghost of Winterfell" was a nice touch of vengeance that got eliminated by killing Mance in an earlier season.  

 

To say something is "needed" is probably not accurate.  I imagine the books won't have a summit with Cersei with a captured wight.  In that case, there won't be an A-Team collection of warriors out on a capture mission where a dragon switches sides.  That whole thing was contrived for a few story points:  1) meet with Cersei; and 2) ice dragon.  I believe the show writers wanted to skip steps to acheive #2.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Somedude   

I have not watched a single trailer. I usually don't care about spoilers but this one I don't want a trailer to even hint as a spoiler.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Somedude said:

I have not watched a single trailer. I usually don't care about spoilers but this one I don't want a trailer to even hint as a spoiler.

Everyone dies.

 

The end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, Jamalisms said:

As I said, the books are massive because they belabor subjects that could be addressed in shorter order, not because they're chock full of new stuff.

 

Personal opinion is that removing FAegon renders Varys' and Illyrio's motivations completely bogus. I've had to explain to many people, including some here in this thread, what is going on there and why they're correct something is weird and unexplained ... because the rationale (and rationale for Dorne as well) was simply cut. FAegon ties a whole lot of shit together.

I agree about Varys and Illyrio’s plot from the book being about FAegon. But I suspect you could write off the TV version as being about supporting Viscerys (and later Dany). 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
21 hours ago, titanruss said:

Nobody who watches the shows gives a damn about the swords. Thats just for the book junkies. 

 

But yeah.. Sam should have to answer for stealing it. They could have just avoided it altogether and had somebody grab it at the war when they got burned up.

You don't think it's significant that so many of the known Valyrian Steel swords in Westeros are either in Winterfell already or headed there?

Or that Gendry, a blacksmith who's the son of a king will be there with them?

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Gendry also worked for the Kings Landing armorer who melted down Ice and turned it into 2 Valyrian steel swords for Tywin. I wonder if they could melt them both back down and reforge Ice when it’s all over with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 minutes ago, Starkiller said:

Gendry also worked for the Kings Landing armorer who melted down Ice and turned it into 2 Valyrian steel swords for Tywin. I wonder if they could melt them both back down and reforge Ice when it’s all over with.

I was trying to think of all the Valyrian Steel that will be there, and it's quite a list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...